How to Choose Softball Gloves For Adults

This guide provides clear instructions for adults to choose, fit, and break in a softball glove. Whether you’re new to softball or upgrading your gear, correctly selecting and preparing your glove enhances performance and comfort. Follow these steps to find a glove that fits well, feels comfortable, and is game-ready.

Difficulty: Beginner | Time: 1-2 hours

Before you orderOffer from Amazon

Get sports gear delivered free with Prime

• Fast, free delivery on millions of items
• Prime Video, Amazon Music and more included
• Member-only deals all year

Start your free Prime trial →Free trial for eligible customers · Cancel anytime

As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.Hide

What You’ll Need

Tools & Materials:

• measuring tape
• glove oil or conditioner (optional)
• soft cloth
• ball or softball

Knowledge:

• basic understanding of softball positions
• ability to measure hand size or glove fit

Set aside at least 1 hour for selection and initial break-in; additional time may be needed for thorough break-in and conditioning.

As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases.

Before You Start

Ensure your hands are clean and dry. Decide on your primary position (e.g., infielder, outfielder) to determine glove type and size. Keep a soft ball handy for break-in exercises. Be aware that a new glove will require some effort to break in for optimal performance.

Step-by-Step Instructions

Step 1: Identify your glove size based on your hand and position

Use a measuring tape to measure the circumference of your hand across the palm, just below the knuckles, excluding the thumb. Refer to standard glove size charts to select a size that matches your position—smaller for infielders, larger for outfielders. For example, 11-11.5 inches for infielders, 12 inches or more for outfielders.

Tip: Try on gloves with similar measurements to verify fit before purchasing. Remember that sizes vary slightly between brands.

Check: You can comfortably fit your hand into the glove with fingers fitting naturally, and the glove covers your palm without excessive tightness or looseness.

Step 2: Select the appropriate glove style and features

Choose a glove designed for adult players with features like a full leather palm, a sturdy yet flexible webbing, and appropriate length. Consider position-specific gloves: smaller gloves for quick infield plays, larger gloves for catching fly balls in the outfield. Look for a glove labeled ‘adult’ or with a recommended size range for adult players.

Tip: Avoid overly stiff or cheap synthetic gloves; invest in a quality glove for durability and performance.

Check: The glove’s webbing and pocket shape suit your playing position and feel comfortable in your hand.

Step 3: Try on the glove to assess fit and comfort

Place your hand inside the glove, ensuring your fingers reach the fingertips comfortably. Check that the glove fits snugly around your palm and wrist without pinching or excessive movement. Make sure your fingers can move freely for quick reactions.

Tip: Wear your typical batting or throwing gloves if you use them, to ensure realistic fit.

Check: Your hand feels secure but not cramped, and you can open and close the glove smoothly.

Step 4: Break in the glove properly

Apply a small amount of glove oil or conditioner evenly across the leather, focusing on the pocket and webbing. Use a soft cloth to spread the oil. Shape the glove into a natural pocket by pressing and forming it around a ball or a glove mallet. Play catch with a soft ball for 15-20 minutes, repeatedly opening and closing the glove to loosen it.

Tip: Avoid over-oiling, which can damage the leather. Work the oil into the glove gradually.

Check: The glove feels softer, more pliable, and the pocket begins to form naturally, making it easier to catch and hold the ball.

Step 5: Shape and form the glove for game readiness

Place a ball or a rolled-up towel inside the pocket and secure it with a rubber band or string. Leave it overnight or for at least 24 hours. This helps mold the glove into a consistent pocket shape suited for catching.

Tip: Repeat the shaping process periodically during the break-in phase.

Check: The glove maintains a firm, well-formed pocket that holds a ball securely and feels comfortable when catching.

Step 6: Test the glove during practice or casual play

Use the glove in actual practice sessions by catching soft throws or balls. Focus on opening and closing the glove smoothly, controlling the ball in the pocket, and maintaining comfort during extended use.

Tip: Adjust the fit with additional conditioning or shaping if needed.

Check: The glove responds well during play, with a secure pocket, comfortable fit, and ease of use.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

• Choosing a glove that’s too stiff or too large — Select a glove that fits snugly and is flexible enough to break in easily; avoid oversized or overly stiff gloves that hinder quick movements.
• Over-oiling the glove — Use oil sparingly and only on the leather, avoiding excessive application which can weaken the material.
• Not shaping the glove during break-in — Regularly shape and mold the glove with a ball or mallet during the break-in process for a natural pocket.

Troubleshooting

Problem: Glove feels too stiff after initial break-in

Solution: Apply a small amount of glove oil and continue to work the leather with your hands and a ball. Use the glove regularly in practice to promote flexibility.

Problem: Pocket collapses or doesn’t hold a ball

Solution: Use a ball or towel to form the pocket overnight. Repeat shaping exercises and play catch frequently to develop a natural pocket.

Problem: The glove fits too tight or causes discomfort

Solution: Remove any excess oil or shaping materials. If still tight, consider using a slightly larger size or loosening the laces if adjustable.

What Success Looks Like

The glove fits snugly but comfortably, forms a natural pocket that securely holds the ball, and responds well during catching and throwing drills. It feels flexible, and you can open and close it smoothly without pinching or excess looseness.

Next Steps

Continue practicing with the glove regularly to maintain flexibility and shape. Periodically clean and condition the leather to keep it in good condition. Replace the glove when it no longer maintains a secure pocket or becomes excessively worn. Consider upgrading to a different size or style as your skill and position evolve.

Frequently Asked Questions

How often should I break in my glove?

Break-in time varies, but generally, it takes about 24-48 hours of regular use and shaping. Use it in practice often to accelerate the process.

Can I use a baseball glove for softball?

While some baseball gloves can be used, softball gloves are typically larger with different webbing suited for the game’s demands. It’s best to choose a glove designed specifically for softball.

How do I maintain my glove over time?

Clean it with a soft cloth and mild leather conditioner periodically. Store it in a cool, dry place and avoid exposing it to extreme heat or moisture.

What size glove should I get for my position?

Infielders usually prefer 11-11.5 inch gloves, outfielders opt for 12 inches or more, and pitchers or catchers have specific sizes and styles. Match the size to your position and hand measurements.

×HALLOWEEN

Halloween Picks

halloween

halloween

View Latest Price

As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.